2026-05-12-ares-phase1-gate-review
title: ARES Phase 1 Gate Review — Waves 1 + 2 date: 2026-05-12 status: ratified mr_compliance: [MR-1, MR-7]
Section titled “title: ARES Phase 1 Gate Review — Waves 1 + 2 date: 2026-05-12 status: ratified mr_compliance: [MR-1, MR-7]”Context
Section titled “Context”Per docs/runbooks/ares-wire-rollout.md, waves 1 (traceo-mcp-server) and 2 (grace-hq) were wired serially on 2026-05-12. The gate review runs after wave 2 completes before Phase 2 pipelining begins.
Gate checklist
Section titled “Gate checklist”- Missing rollback path? No.
gh api -X DELETE /orgs/<org>/hooks/<id>is documented indocs/runbooks/ares-wire-rollout.md§“Rollback (whole programme)” and cited in each consumer repo’s deployment doc path. - Unsafe sandbox interaction? No. Webhook secret was retrieved from Railway and piped directly into
gh api -f "config[secret]=..."without ever being echoed or committed. - Hard-coded value needing placeholder? No. The ingest endpoint (
cicd.devarno.cloud) and webhook event (workflow_run) are stable deployment facts, not environment-specific placeholders. - Procedural surprises requiring prompt update? No. The procedure ran as documented.
Wave outcomes
Section titled “Wave outcomes”| Wave | Repo | Org webhook ID | Scope | Contract status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | traceo-mcp-server | 622165750 | org (traceo-ai) | wired |
| 2 | grace-hq | 622165757 | org (grace-hq) | wired |
Gate verdict
Section titled “Gate verdict”Pass. No fixes to core/prompts/06-ares-wire.md required. Proceed to Phase 2.
Phase 2 waves (3a choco-hq, 3b stratt-hq, 3c devarno-cloud, 3d kahn-hq) may now be pipelined per the runbook’s pipelining rule.